Behavioral economics enriches the conventional economics toolbox by incorporating insights from psychology, neuroscience, sociology, politics, and the law. Pdf a behavioral approach to law and economics cass. Posner introduction jolls, sunstein, and thaler wish to use the insights of behavioral economics to improve economic analysis of law, which they believe to be handicapped by its commitment to the assumption that people are rational. A behavioral approach to law and economics by cass r. This expansion has established a new field behavioral law and economics ble.
Christine jolls also notes that behavioral economics attempts to improve the. Part ii examines how a behaviorallyinformed law and economics analysis can help to explain the behavior of human agents. The behavioral economics on the other hand questions and successfully challenges this underlying assumption of rationality. The chicago school argues that irrationality is the antithesis of rational markets. It considers specific topics in the economic analysis of law and proposes new models and approaches for addressing these topics. Behavioral economics studies the effects of psychological, cognitive, emotional, cultural and social factors on the economic decisions of individuals and institutions and how those decisions vary from those implied by classical theory. A behavioral approach to law and economics the harvard community has made this article openly available. A behavioral law and economics approach to childhood immunization policy i. See also russel korobkin, what comes after victory for behavioral law and economics, 5 u. The first synthesis of law and economics took place several decades ago, based on the seminal work of nobel prize winning chicago economist. Sunstein, and richard thaler economic analysis of law usually proceeds under the assumptions of neoclassical economics. Behavioral law and economics cambridge series on judgment and decision making. Columbia university this paper examines the implications of the brain sciences mechanistic model of human behavior for our understanding of crime.
But empirical evidence gives much reason io doubl these. Pdf a behavioral approach to law and economics semantic. This article offers a broad vision of how law and economics analysis may be improved by increased attention to insights about actual human behavior. Second, i will highlight some potential challenges to the approach with a view on the relevant unit of analysis and. Behavioral economics takes standard economics as its departure point, but then proposes its own models expressly designed around the anomalous empirical data. Behavioral economics applied to energy demand analysis. Becker, the economic approach to human behavior 1976 p. Can behavioral economics generate a unitary theory of behavior, or is it. In order to identify, in a general way, the defining features of behavioral law and economics, it is useful first to understand the defining features of law and economics. Some observations on behavioral economics and the creation of the consumer financial protection agency, remarks at the conference on the regulation of. Behavioral law and economics is not just a refinement of law and.
Where the former is seldom used in international law and economics, the latter has been softened through the developments in behavioral economics at least in national law and economics. This edited collection shows that the approach he has been working on for the past several years, has finally come of age. Rational choice, behavioral economics, and the law richard a. Bles principal insight is that human behavior commonly deviates. The oxford handbook of behavioral economics and law brings together leading scholars of law, psychology, and economics to provide an uptodate and comprehensive analysis of this field of research, including its strengths and limitations as well as a forecast of its future development. Provides a critical introduction to the heuristics and biases literature, human pro. Economic analysis of law usually proceeds under the assumptions of neoclassical economics. See infra notes 8789 and accompanying text discussing the. One possible approach to normative analysis when the value of an.
They then systematically examine the empirical evidence inconsistent with the rationality assumption and, drawing on a widerange of substantive areas of law, explain how normative policy conclusions of law and economics will change and improve. Behavioral law and economics is not just a refinement of. Sunstein and richard thaler, reprinted in the international library of essays in law and legal theory, 2nd series, eric a. Notwithstanding the results so far provided by the behavioral approach are somehow. Applying behavioral economics to improve microsavings outcomes 6 our work began by carefully defining the problem. Resume index plan texte bibliographie notes citation auteur. First, i will provide a short overview of economic analysis of international law, behavioral economics, and political psychology in international relations. The oxford handbook of behavioral economics and the law. Law and economics analysis is normatively committed to using legal policy to promote the efficient production and allocation of resources and consequently the maximization of social welfare. I then offer indicative behavioral research frameworks for three contemporary puzzles in international law. Behavioral international law and economics anne van aaken whereas the rational choice approach to international law has been widely accepted in legal scholarship and international relations theory, challenges to the rational choice paradigm in economic analysis of international law have hitherto not been systematically explored. But empirical evidence gives much reason to doubt these. Articles a behavioral approach to law and economics.
Behavioral economics guide 2016 vii various purposes, such as for deciding whether to send a patient to the coronary care unit, inferring whether patients are infected with. But empirical evidence gives much reason to doubt these assumptions. As we understand it, this approach to the law posits that. The first comprehensive and systematic introduction to behavioral legal studies. Behavioral law and economics northwestern pritzker school of law. Behavioral public choice is both an extension of and a reaction to behavioral economics and its counterpart in legal scholarship, behavioral law and economics. Sunstein, and richard thaler economic analysis of law usually proceeds under the assumptions of neo. Parts ii and iii of the article involve positive analysis. An unquestioned centerpiece of law and economics is the coase theorem coase 1960. This paper describes and assesses the current state of behavioral law and economics. By christine jolls, massachusetts institute of technology. The psychological foundations of behavioral law and economics. In order use law to promote efficiency, analysts must make assumptions about how actors will respond to the incentives created by legal rules. On the behavioral economics of crime frans van winden and elliott ash university of amsterdam.
Iii of the article considers whether behavioral law and economics is up to the task. The key difference is that behavioral law and economics uses more realistic descriptions of human behavior as its foundation. Unfortunately, this bottomup approach leaves behavioral economics without the unifying conceptual 10. Articles a behavioral approach to law and economics christine jolls, cass r. A behavioral approach to law and economics with cass r. The value of behavioral economics for eu judicial decision. Behavioral economics and the law christine jolls gordon bradford tweedy professor of law and organization, yale law school, new haven, ct, usa, christine. This article offers a broad vision of how law and economics analysis may be. Behavioral economics has been a growing force in many fields of applied economics, including public economics, labor economics, health economics, and law and economics. In this essay we assess its relevance for the theory of optimal law enforcement.
Rachlinski over the past decade, psychological research has enjoyed a rapidly expanding influence on legal scholarship. A behavioral approach to law and economics chapter 1. Law and economics or economic analysis of law is the application of economic theory specifically microeconomic theory to the analysis of law that began mostly with scholars from the chicago school of economics. A behavioral approach to law and economics christine jolls, cass r. Sunstein, and richard thaler economic analysis of law usually proceeds under the assumptions of neo classical economics. A number of prominent advocates of applying behavioral economics to the law make the claim that behavioral law and economics is simply a refinement of traditional law and economics. In law and economics today, both the endowment effect and other features. The key difference is that behavioral law and economics uses more realistic. Behavioral economics is primarily concerned with the bounds of rationality of economic agents. It is our view that criminal law is an area where behavioral analysis has a role to play. Behavioral economics to appear in elseviers handbook. Thaler, supra note 31, at 269 providing a view that is a. Economic concepts are used to explain the effects of laws, to assess which legal rules are economically efficient, and to predict which legal rules will be promulgated.
Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. A behavioral approach to law and economics by christine. Kt man, and the future of behavioral law and economics, 56 vand. A behavioral approach to problemsolving begins by defining the problem in terms of specific human behaviors. Pdf economic analysis of law usually proceeds under the assumptions of neoclassical economics. Wanner describes behavioral economics as an application of cognitive science to the realm of economic decisionmaking. Behavioral economic analysis of law is about bringing recent research about behavior and choice together with classical law and economics. Applying behavioral economics to improve microsavings. The psychological foundations of behavioral law and. Thaler,a behavioral approach to law and economics, 50 stan. Foundations of behavioral law and economics jeffrey j. The behavioral in behavioral law and economics is about infusing law and economics with insights into actual rather than hypothesized human behavior when such insights are needed to insure. The standard rationalchoice crime model is refined by a behavioral.
1095 432 484 1321 80 1249 312 268 36 605 1340 971 1125 484 453 1066 129 193 966 1492 1449 1644 555 21 1214 1270 480 151 792 1483 780 521 540 1222